Thursday, March 14, 2013

Baseball as a Road to God


NYU President John Sexton has written a book Baseball as a Road to God, based on a course he gives with the same title.  He gave an NPR interview about his book on the Leonard Lopate Show.
To listen to it, visit  http://www.wnyc.org/shows/lopate/2013/mar/13/nyu-president-baseball-road-god/
Click on the (lower) "Listen", just above the photo of Busch Stadium.

Three things stood out for me:

1.  You're born into a team, like a religion:  "We're bequeathed our team."  This was my experience, although in an unusual way. When I was 4 or going on 4, my oldest brother had me point at a list of teams in a newspaper, and, seeing which team I'd pointed at, declared that I was a Cincinnati Redlegs fan. And that was that. This is one of my earliest memories, I wasn't sure that it really happened until he confirmed it a few years ago.

Sexton adds that this early choice of a team is more important than the early choice of a religion, because the choice of a team is more likely to stick.  Certainly true in my case. On a related note, he says:  "It gets you when you're young, in which case it sticks, or not at all."

2.  His most interesting statement, about what Americans, in particular the citizens of Brooklyn, learned in 1958:
"If the Dodgers could be taken from Brooklyn, there's no institution we can trust."
Historians see the New York Giants leaving for San Francisco and the Brooklyn Dodgers leaving for Los Angeles - both in 1958 - as an indicator of a turning point in 20th century US history.

3. Toward the end they mention Bart Giamatti,  whom I knew at Yale before he became the President of Yale.  Later he became the Commissioner of Baseball.  He has written beautiful essays on the spiritual side of baseball, which were collected into a book Green Fields of the Mind, which is required reading for the course.

I have a Bart Giamatti story which captures (1) above, I'll save it for a live telling.

His only mention of God is in the context of prayer.  He refers to a God within and unnamed Asian religions. About prayer: "Prayer changes the one who prays."

One for you Ted:  He refers to an article that uses phenomenology to interpret the ritual of a baseball game as based on the ritual of a  Mass.

Refers to John Updike's poem: Tao in the Yankee Stadium Bleachers.

Religious themes:
Fatih and doubt.
Faith: Tug McGraw's "You gotta believe"  seemed to carry the underdog 1973 Mets to a World Series.

Doubt:  "Baseball incarnates doubt."

Curses & Blessings:
  blessing - a release from accursedness

Brooklyn Dodger fans responded to a curse with hope -  "Wait Till Next Year", which finally arrived in 1955.
Cubs fans, who are still waiting, respond with humor "The Cubs just had an off century."
(Based on the cliche "The team just had an off day.")

Religions advise against hubris.  So does baseball.
"In baseball, a player better have humility, or he will fail."

The sacred and the profane:  the baseball - the sacred rock; the baseball stadium - the sacred shrine.

Things he doesn't mention:

In Bull Durham,  Susan Sarandon played a woman who was very into 3 things: religion, baseball, and sex.  She observed that the number of beads in a rosary is the same as the number of stitches in a baseball.

The Holy Trinity and baseball as the game of threes.  Three strikes to an out, three outs to an inning, three innings for each of the three (beginning, middle, and end) parts of a game.

Also, quite remarkably, on average over time, a batter safely reaches base one in three times at bat, and a team scores a run (or more) in one of three innings.

This is the source of the statement "Failure is the norm" in baseball.

5 comments:

TFZ said...

Mike, I appreciate your thoroughness ,your Grundlichkeit!

Watching the Game with a friend is fun. Thanks for connecting me ... around 1968.

Baseball's rhythm of sloooow, slow, fast! make me grin. It has many examples about paying attention when an inning seems slow.

TFZ said...

re: thoroughness
BULL DURHAM has been queued on my netflix account. My partner and I will watch it.

TFZ said...

Like an unadorned Christmas tree, Mike's post calls for decoration.

This Sunday morning I hang a comment railing against pro Football and the NFL. My hanging looks like a bundle of straw with a large needle run through it. In fact, the straw bundle is an NFL-action-doll!

A perspective on why NFL-television is so popular arrived on my philosophy-while-driving channel... Pro Football is so popular because 'we' are alienated from the ground of our being.
Duh??
Ground of Being pays tribute to philosophy talks Mike and I had shared; and the Literati upon whose shoulders we have walked. These giants include E Husserl, Heidigger, and most recently David Abrams.
Alienation pays tribute to the linguistic contributions of philosophy.
As descendants of the Paleolithic Era, we still need spectacles like 'the' Super Bowl.

This comment uses an 'editorial we', a posture that inflates but ultimately alienates me from yes ... the ground of my humble being. Rest assured I shall return (and Recover) to first person singular!

Mike said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mike said...

The Romans, unemcumbered by Christian guilt, did not go about
their pleasures in a half-hearted way. Their spectacles at
the Roman Colosseum, with blood spilling and spilled by
big cats, slave warriors, etc., serving spectator bloodlust,
is best represented today in the US by NFL football, a game
whose violence has grown with the size and speed of the players
- 300+ pound linemen who run with the speed of high school
sprinters - played in front of screaming and hysterical
spectators, lusting for the blood of the visiting team.

The crowd plays the role of a '12th man' - a vital addition
to the 11 players on the field for the home team.
Seattle Seahawks' fans broke the Guinness World Record for
crowd noise at 137.6 decibels during a game. A jet engine
at 100 feet is about 140 decibels. The Seahawks' 12th Man
also caused some quake-like shakes: a University of
Washington earth sciences professor said the legendary
noisemaking of their fans registered on a nearby seismometer
with roughly the same energy as a magnitude 1 or 2 earthquake
during the game.

Nietzche also disdained the 'editorial we,' but not out
of modesty. After a use if it, he parenthetically added
that he was only using it out of politeness.